[SidneyMerk.com]

[MakingAdventures]

My IF Games

Trading Punches
The Swordsman
Insanity Circle
Breath Pirates
Mystic Force
Hallowmoor
Distress

My Reviews

Fall Comp 2008
Fall Comp 2007
Fall Comp 2006
Fall Comp 2005
Fall Comp 2004


Spring 2006
C32 Comp 2004
Misc Reviews

Miscellaneous

IntFiction Forum
Older IF News
Lunatix Online
StarLock RPG
About Me

Other IF Links

IF Competition
The IF Archive
SPAG Online
XYZZY News
IF Database
Baf's Guide
IF Reviews
The IF Wiki

Email Me At

[sid_ney_merk_@_hot_mail_.com]

Reviews of the IF COMP 2005 Games

     Before reading each review, I recommend that you look over the introduction, which I wrote before playing any of the games. Also, read through my scoring explanation (it describes the base score assigned to each game -- when I skew a rating up or down, the resulting score does not necessarily equate to any base score). You can also see my complete review journal on a single (very long) page (you have been warned). Otherwise, each piece is available separately via the links below. (Note: Go here for the official competition results.)

 #  In Order Played    #  In Order By Score Base Skew Total
1 Century Cauldron   1 Beyond 10.0 none 10.0
2 Amissville II   2 Chancellor 9.5 none 9.5
3 Space Horror Part I   3 Vespers 9.0 +0.5 9.5
4 Psyche's Lament   4 The Colour Pink 9.0 +0.5 9.5
5 Gilded: Lily & Cage   5 Unforgotten 8.5 +1.0 9.5
6 Vespers   6 Gilded: Lily & Cage 9.0 none 9.0
7 Vendetta   7 Son of a... 8.5 +0.5 9.0
8 The Colour Pink   8 Tough Beans 8.5 +0.5 9.0
9 Xen: The Contest   9 Space Horror Part I 8.5 +0.5 9.0
10 Snatches   10 Mortality 9.0 -0.5 8.5
11 Beyond   11 A New Life 7.5 +0.5 8.0
12 Internal Vigilance   12 Snatches 8.0 -0.5 7.5
13 History Repeating   13 Escape to New York 7.0 +0.5 7.5
14 A New Life   14 Xen: The Contest 7.0 +0.5 7.5
15 FutureGame   15 History Repeating 7.0 +0.5 7.5
16 Son of a...   16 Waldo's Pie 7.5 -0.5 7.0
17 The Plague (Redux)   17 Internal Vigilance 7.0 none 7.0
18 The Sword of Malice   18 Mix Tape 7.0 none 7.0
19 Tough Beans   19 Psyche's Lament 6.5 none 6.5
20 Off the Trolley   20 Century Cauldron 5.5 +1.0 6.5
21 Neon Nirvana   21 Jesus of Nazareth 5.5 +1.0 6.5
22 Jesus of Nazareth   22 On Optimism 6.0 none 6.0
23 Unforgotten   23 Vendetta 5.0 +1.0 6.0
24 Phantom: Caverns   24 Off the Trolley 5.0 +1.0 6.0
25 Escape to New York   25 Neon Nirvana 6.0 -0.5 5.5
26 Cheiron   26 The Plague (Redux) 5.5 -0.5 5.0
27 Hello Sword   27 Dreary Lands 4.0 +0.5 4.5
28 PTBAD6andoneeighth   28 The Sword of Malice 4.0 none 4.0
29 Waldo's Pie   29 Amissville II 4.0 -0.5 3.5
30 Mix Tape   30 Hello Sword 2.0 +1.0 3.0
31 Ninja II   31 Phantom: Caverns 2.5 none 2.5
32 Mortality   32 Cheiron 1.5 +0.5 2.0
33 Dreary Lands   33 FutureGame 2.0 -0.5 1.5
34 On Optimism   34 Ninja II 2.0 -1.0 1.0
35 Chancellor   35 PTBAD6andoneeighth 1.5 -1.0 0.5
    Distress No Score (mine)

     Above, the games are listed twice. First, they are shown in the order I played. Next, they are in order by total score. When sorting games with the same total score, the base score (without a skew) is used to put them in order. If the base is also the same, then I have simply picked the one that was more fun or more appealing to me.

     These reviews comprise my take on the competition. Even though I write this a few days prior to the announcement of the official results, I suspect that some of the games I found most enjoyable may rank lower in the final tally.

     I refined my scoring criteria this year. The result is a set of scores that averages lower than last year, where twenty-four of the thirty-five other games were given an 8.0 or higher (this year, only eleven). I don't think the games were weaker or less enjoyable this year, so keep that in mind when comparing these to my prior rankings. My average score this year is just under 6.5.